Talk to a top lawyer for free

What does dismissed with prejudice mean?

Dismissed with prejudice means your case is over for good. Learn how to get your get dismissed with prejudice, what it means for criminal cases, and more.

evident Editorial Team
August 15, 2023
justice, statue, lady justice

The term "dismissed with prejudice" can hold profound implications, particularly for a person charged with a crime. But what does it mean when a case is dismissed with prejudice? This legal jargon is more than just esoteric courtroom vocabulary - it directly influences the course and outcome of court proceedings.

This article will explain what "dismissed with prejudice" means, the circumstances under which a case is dismissed, and how it differs from being "dismissed without prejudice." We will also explore related legal concepts, such as double jeopardy, voluntary and involuntary dismissals. The aim is to equip you with essential knowledge that might come in handy in your legal journey.

Let's get into it.

Key Takeaways

Dismissed With Prejudice Explained

"Dismissed with prejudice" means your court case has been dismissed permanently. The same parties involved in the original lawsuit cannot bring the case back before the court. In essence, when a case is dismissed with prejudice, it is over and done with, in the same way as if there had been a trial, and a final determination had been reached.

The term 'prejudice' here does not refer to bias or discrimination. Instead, it denotes a legal impediment or barrier against bringing the same charges against the defendant in the future. A dismissal with prejudice exists to bring finality to a case. 

When Dismissal with Prejudice Occurs

Dismissal with prejudice usually happens when a judge believes that the case has serious flaws, which could be due to a variety of reasons, such as lack of probable cause, illegal search and seizure, or even an improper venue.

It might also occur if the plaintiff or prosecutor consistently fails to follow court rules or when the case has been brought to court and dismissed several times. In such situations, the judge decides enough is enough, and it's time to end the cycle by dismissing the case with prejudice.

However, the decision to dismiss a case with prejudice is not taken lightly. It often comes after the judge has given ample warnings and opportunities to correct the issues. In many jurisdictions, judges must explain why they chose to dismiss a case with prejudice.

It's also worth noting that a dismissal with prejudice doesn't necessarily mean the defendant is innocent of the criminal charges. Instead, it means that due to certain legal or procedural flaws, the court has decided that the case cannot proceed and the same criminal charge cannot be brought again. l

Every case is unique, and it is crucial to consult a defense attorney to understand how this concept applies to your situation.

What is a Dismissal Without Prejudice

A dismissal without prejudice, unlike its counterpart, means that you've had your case dismissed, but it is not a final dismissal. If a case is dismissed without prejudice, the same charges or case can be brought again later. 

This kind of dismissal often happens when there are correctable issues with the case or the paperwork or if the case is dismissed for procedural reasons. For example, the case may be dismissed without prejudice if the court lacks subject matter jurisdiction or personal jurisdiction, and the correct court is yet to be determined.

With Prejudice vs. Without Prejudice

The distinction between dismissal with prejudice and without prejudice essentially boils down to the finality of the decision. Dismissal with prejudice is a final determination, closing the case once and for all. It protects defendants from being prosecuted over the same charges or having to repeatedly defend themselves against the same allegations. 

On the other hand, dismissal without prejudice indicates a temporary halt rather than a final closure. It allows the plaintiff or the prosecution to correct any errors and refile the case.

Understanding these differences can be vital, especially when dealing with criminal charges where the stakes are high. Therefore, always consult with your defense attorney to comprehend the implications fully.

Double Jeopardy

prison, prison cell, jail

Double jeopardy is pivotal in criminal law, ensuring a person isn't subjected to multiple prosecutions for the same offense. Enshrined in the Fifth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution, it protects individuals from being tried twice for the same crime in the same jurisdiction, provided the first trial has been concluded.

Double jeopardy is closely related to the concept of dismissal with prejudice. Once a criminal case is dismissed with prejudice, the principle of double jeopardy comes into play, protecting the defendant from being prosecuted again on the same charges. It shields individuals from the stress, expense, and potential harassment of being tried repeatedly for the same crime.

However, it's essential to understand that double jeopardy applies only after a trial has reached a point known as 'jeopardy attachment,' usually when the jury is empaneled and sworn in or, in a bench trial, when the first witness is sworn in. It does not apply if a case was dismissed without prejudice before this point, as the prosecution has the right to refile charges.

Navigating these complexities can be challenging, making it vital to engage a knowledgeable defense attorney to protect your rights in the face of criminal charges.

Types of Dismissal

The legal journey of a court case can end in several ways, one of which is dismissal. However, not all dismissals are the same. They fall into two main categories: voluntary and involuntary dismissal.

Voluntary Dismissal

Voluntary dismissal is when the person who initiated the case, either the plaintiff in a civil case or the prosecutor in a criminal case, decides to discontinue the proceedings. A party may voluntarily dismiss a case due to reaching an out-of-court settlement, a plea deal, or simply deciding not to pursue the case further. All they need to do is file a few court forms requesting dismissal.

In criminal cases, voluntary dismissal is also known as nolle prosequi. It signifies that the prosecutor has decided to drop the charges, often due to lack of evidence, unwillingness of witnesses to testify, or in light of new information that undermines the viability of the prosecution.

justice, right, legal

It's worth noting that voluntary dismissals can be either with or without prejudice. When the dismissal is with prejudice, the case can't be brought back to court. However, if it's without prejudice, the prosecutor retains the right to refile charges.

Involuntary Dismissal

On the other hand, involuntary dismissal occurs when the judge decides to end the case, usually due to some procedural issue, legal deficiency, or at the defendant's request. In a criminal case, an involuntary dismissal might occur if the court lacks jurisdiction, the prosecution fails to provide sufficient evidence, or the statute of limitations expires.

Involuntary dismissals can also be either with or without prejudice, based on the judge's decision.

In both voluntary and involuntary dismissals, it's critical to understand the implications and your rights, particularly if you're the defendant.

Can I Request the Court Dismiss My Case With Prejudice?

A common question asked by defendants facing criminal charges is whether they can request the court to dismiss their case with prejudice. The short answer is yes, you can make such a request. However, it's up to the court whether to grant the request.

judge, hammer, judgement

Defendants can file a motion to dismiss their case, stating why they believe it should be dismissed with prejudice. This usually happens when there are significant procedural issues, such as a lack of evidence, violations of the defendant's constitutional rights, or the prosecution's failure to meet legal requirements.

This complex legal maneuver requires a deep understanding of criminal law and court proceedings. Crafting a compelling motion involves strategic legal argumentation and presentation of evidence, and not every request will be granted. You can always appeal to a higher court if your request is denied.

Therefore, it's advisable to consult with an experienced defense attorney before making such a request to fully comprehend the implications and potential consequences.

FAQs related to 'dismissed with prejudice'

Why would a judge dismiss a case with prejudice?

A judge might dismiss a case with prejudice for several reasons. These include a lack of evidence, repeated failures by the prosecution to follow court rules, violation of the defendant's constitutional rights, or lack of jurisdiction. In some cases, the same case might have been brought to court and dismissed several times, prompting the judge to dismiss with prejudice to prevent repeated litigation.

What is dismissal with prejudice example?

Let's consider an example to illustrate a dismissal with prejudice. Suppose John was charged with theft. However, the prosecution repeatedly failed to provide substantial evidence to support the charges. After several warnings, the judge finally dismissed the case with prejudice. This means John can't be charged again for the same offense, giving him legal closure.

What is the meaning of 'with prejudice'?

In legal parlance, 'with prejudice' means a case is dismissed permanently. The phrase doesn't indicate bias or discrimination but denotes a legal barrier preventing the same case from being brought back to court by the same parties.

What does dismissed with prejudice mean in California?

In California, as in other states, when a case is dismissed with prejudice, it indicates a permanent dismissal. It means that the case is closed and cannot be brought back to the court again by the same parties on the same charges. California law also adheres to 'double jeopardy,' preventing a defendant from being prosecuted twice for the same offense once a case has been dismissed with prejudice.

The Bottom Line

Understanding the complexities of legal terminology and processes is critical, especially when faced with a criminal case. A term like "dismissed with prejudice" might seem daunting. Still, it signifies an important protective measure within our legal system that prevents individuals from facing repetitive litigation for the same offense.

Whether you're the defendant in a criminal case or a curious citizen, understanding these concepts is essential to navigating the legal landscape effectively. However, every case is unique, and seeking professional legal advice is always advisable if you find yourself entangled in a legal matter.